Duplicate title
A replacement title costs $25, online or by mail, and can take up to 10 days. Paid-off liens need the lender's original release.
Read the Massachusetts rule in full
The RMV charges $25 for a replacement paper title. Individuals apply online in myRMV with a MyMassGov account (businesses need their FID number), or mail the Application for Duplicate Certificate of Title with a check or money order payable to MassDOT to the RMV Title Division, P.O. Box 55885, Boston, MA 02205-5885; in-person filing isn't described. Have the VIN or title number and your driver's license number; if a loan was ever recorded, include the original lien release (or a letter on lender letterhead listing year, make, VIN and all owners; no faxes or copies), and for a deceased owner include a letter of administration, a court order or the Affidavit of Surviving Spouse plus the death certificate.
A titled car can't skip the duplicate when sold for junk, because the junk buyer must surrender the title to the RMV (§20E). With E-Title live, the RMV also offers a $25 Replace/Convert application for switching between paper and electronic titles in either direction.
Sources
M.G.L. c. 90D §14 · M.G.L. c. 90D §20E